Credibility under threat
Russell Silberston – Strategist
In our last three policy reviews, we have mapped the evolution of major central banks’ stance as a path which started off as an orderly exit from super-loose monetary policy, but became a rush when the evidence suggested inflation was more persistent than expected. As prices took another lurch higher, panic set in in the first quarter of this year.
In the second quarter of 2022, with inflation continuing to surprise to the upside and evidence that it is spreading to a wider range of goods and services, those policy makers are now fighting for their most powerful weapon, namely their credibility.
The Fed leads the charge
The US Federal Reserve (Fed) is leading the charge, raising official interest rates by 125bps over the quarter, starting quantitative tightening and guiding that policy rates will likely need to be restrictive by the end of this year. Its actions are perhaps best described by Chair Powell, who in an interview in May was asked “what is Jay Powell thinking in 5 words or less?” His answer was simply “get inflation back under control.” To achieve this, the consensus on the rate-setting Federal Open Market Committee is that Fed Funds need to reach 3.1% to 3.6% by December, the upper end of which is well above the Committee’s assessment of economically neutral interest rates of 2.5%.
The Fed makes no effort to hide the fact that such aggressive tightening could have unintended consequences, but as Governor Michelle Bowman noted in June, “these actions do not come without risk…but in my view, our number one responsibility is to reduce inflation. Maintaining our commitment to restore price stability is the best course to support a sustainably strong labour market. The Fed’s credibility, earned over decades of low inflation, is a powerful tool that is critical to our long-term success. If that credibility erodes, it must be re-earned.” We have no reason to doubt the Fed’s strong message and it will be loath to declare victory on inflation too early, rather it wants to see “clear and convincing” evidence that inflation is coming down. The ‘Fed put,’ therefore, is well out of the money.
The ECB’s lack of clarity
With inflation having risen from 1.9% to 8.6% in 12 months, the European Central Bank’s (ECB) credibility is also on the line. In May, President Lagarde took to the ECB’s blog to “clarify the path of policy normalisation that lies ahead of us” and acknowledged that “the disinflationary dynamics of the past decade are unlikely to return. As a result, it is appropriate for policy to return to more normal settings rather than those aimed at raising inflation from very low levels.” She effectively then went on to pre-announce the end of quantitative easing, an interest rate hike this month and an exit from negative interest rates by the end of the third quarter. Beyond that, the path for monetary policy is defined as “gradual but sustained” with the option of ditching this approach were inflation expectations to show signs of becoming unanchored. The problem for the ECB’s approach is it is deliberately avoiding discussion of neutral policy and so the market has no anchor to judge whether interest rates are loose, neutral or tight. With markets priced for 190bps of increases between July and December followed by cuts in 2023, some much needed clarity would be welcome.
The Bank of England’s balancing act
With the worst growth and inflation outlook of all major economies, the Bank of England (BoE) is taking a different approach, attempting to balance the trade-offs inherent in the grim forecasts. The various weights different Monetary Policy Committee members place on these explains why we have seen votes ranging from unchanged interest rates to increases of 25bps and 50bps over recent months. The BoE’s chosen solution to this is to focus on the persistent elements of inflation, such as domestic prices and wages and attempt to look through the volatility of energy prices. Having already raised the base rate to 1.25%, 50 bps above the post-GFC high, and commenced quantitative tightening, its guidance has therefore turned more cautious, noting that “the scale, pace and timing of any further increases in Bank Rate will reflect the Committee’s assessment of the economic outlook and inflationary pressures.” However, were it to see “more persistent inflationary pressures”, the Bank would “act forcefully in response.” Markets have failed to acknowledge the Bank’s relative caution and discount a further 190bps of increases in Bank Rate. With the economy already flirting with recession, this seems very aggressive and would leave Bank Rate at 3.00%, a level last seen on the eve of the Global Financial Crisis.
Bank of Japan’s commitment in question
The Bank of Japan (BoJ) is also fighting for its credibility, but for very different reasons. With national CPI running at 2.5%, financial markets are questioning the Bank’s commitment to yield curve control by trying to push 10-year Japanese Government Bond yields through the upper band of 0.25%. In response, at the end of April, the BoJ offered to buy unlimited bonds every business day in an attempt to hold the line. So far, its actions have held the sellers in check, but at the cost of a massively weak yen, which has been undermined by the differing policy stances of the Fed and BoJ. In the latter’s view, the key to seeing sustained at target inflation is over-coming what Governor Kuroda describes as the zero-inflation norm price setting behaviour of Japanese firms, who in turn respond to consumers’ lack of appetite for higher prices. For this to occur, wages need to rise so that the population are better able to pay higher prices, creating a virtuous circle. Having said that, the BoJ believes there are early signs of a change in consumer attitudes, and we believe that there is also evidence of a broadening out in Japanese inflation, perhaps opening the door of the Bank of Japan to begin policy normalisation in the months ahead.
China sets its own path
The People’s Bank of China (PBOC), in complete contrast to most other central banks, has an easing bias in order to bolster growth against the economic cost of the zero-COVID policy and the major correction in property. However, there was no wholesale easing of monetary policy but rather small, focused initiatives such as guiding mortgage rates modestly lower and allowing day-to-day liquidity to drift below official interest rates. The PBOC has also been encouraging banks to support small and medium-sized business as well as fund China’s green transition. The focused nature of these policies was reflected in a recent speech by Governor Li Gang, delivered in English, and so meant for an international audience. He emphasised that real interest rates were already quite low, thus appearing to rule out cuts in official interest rates. Indeed, with recent economic data showing signs of stabilisation and COVID subsiding in June, the PBOC has actually started draining liquidity from money markets, forcing day-to-day cash up modestly. Fiscal policy on the other hand, at both state and local authority level, appears to be very loose, with suggestions that borrowing is brought forward in order to bolster growth in the second half of the year.