The Fed stays patient
Russell Silberston – Strategist
There were no significant changes to the Federal Reserve’s (Fed) monetary policy stance over the first quarter, despite large upward revisions to the economic outlook. The Fed’s new policy review, discussed in our last quarterly, is now guided by realised outcomes rather than economic forecasts. As such, and despite revising its 2021 economic growth forecast from 4.2% to 6.5% while anticipating unemployment at 3.5% by 2023 along with inflation very modestly above target, the Federal Open Market Committee kept its median interest rate guidance unchanged to ensure the anticipated reversion to full employment and modestly above-target inflation was realised in practice. Patience rather than pre-emptive action is the communication; in effect, by keeping policy on hold into what promises to be one of the strongest years for economic growth in decades, it will become looser the longer that growth holds up. The Fed has communicated very clearly that higher government bond yields will be tolerated if markets are orderly and the rise is associated with an improving economic outlook.
The reason for such a favourable outlook was the enormous US$1.9 trillion fiscal package recently launched by the Biden administration, and made possible by their taking effective control of Congress early in January. The most eye-catching element of the latest package is the direct payment of $1,400 per eligible person, larger than the $1,200 made earlier in 2020 and $600 made in December. These are means tested, but at a relatively high level of $75,000 for individuals and $150,000 for couples. There is an additional payment of $1,400 for each dependent child. Markets are expecting that much of the stimulus will be spent, reflected in the Bloomberg Household Consumption growth rate consensus forecast, which now stands at 6.1% for 2021, an increase from 4.6% at the end of 2020, and 3.9% at the end of September.
Chinese policy remains neutral
China retained its neutral monetary policy stance, with recent communication from People’s Bank of China (PBOC) Governor Yi Gang stressing “consistency, stability and sustainability” of policy. Given the large build-up of debt in China, which stood at 285% of GDP at the end of September1, the PBOC is trying to “strike a good balance between supporting growth and preventing risks,” according to the Governor. The PBOC’s focus on rural development and aid for small and medium sized enterprises looks set to continue and major banks are expected to keep lending generously to the sector whilst also trying to reduce real interest rates. Of course, the Bank is not independent and implements guidance from the Chinese Politburo, which in this year’s Government Work Report suggested money supply needs to grow in line with nominal GDP. Using the 2021 Bloomberg consensus forecast for real GDP and CPI, this suggests a 10% growth rate this year, a little slower than the 10.5% seen for M2 money supply growth in 2020. However, so far this year, the growth of Total Social Financing – the broad measure of financing in China – is running comfortably ahead of this level.
Fiscal policy looks to be unchanged this year, with the Government Work Report suggesting a budget deficit of 3.2% of GDP, a stance described by the authorities as “proactive” and likely necessary to support employment. Having set a floor for GDP growth this year of 6% against expectations of 8.5%, the authorities have plenty of fiscal wiggle room though and can take further action to boost China’s relatively poor social security safety net and help boost consumption.
Europe sees a subtle shift
Eurozone monetary policy shifted subtly during the quarter. Having used the Pandemic Emergency Purchase Programme (PEPP) to keep financial conditions loose last year, guidance has been firmed up such that financial conditions need to be appropriate for the economic outlook. This means that, in practice, higher government bond yields and more expensive bank lending rates will be tolerated if they are in response to improving economic prospects. If, however, the Governing Council judges that markets are running ahead of economic reality, it will step up its intervention. Given the EU’s stalling vaccine rollout and a third wave of virus cases keeping economies constrained, the Governing Council increased the pace of monthly bond purchases at its March meeting. Unlike the Federal Reserve, the ECB has set a pre-determined ‘envelope’ for the PEPP, which stands at €1.85 trillion and is open until March 2022. With a 3-month average run rate of €57 billion to end Feb-21, much of this capacity was going to be left unused, but with the recent communication, it appears that purchases will be upped substantially, most likely to €75bn per month, an amount that would fulfil the full size of the QE package this time next year.
Eurozone fiscal policy might be at a crossroads. The foundational Maastricht Criteria has been quietly sidelined and it is widely acknowledged that a new fiscal framework is needed whilst the NextGenerationEU, the EU’s programme of grants and loans to rebuild post-COVID would have been unthinkable ten years ago. The real test will come after the pandemic, but for now, fiscal policy in Europe remains loose as a combination of automatic stabilisers and specific virus-related spending keeps Northern European debt fears at bay. However, with Mario Draghi now Italian Prime Minister and Christine Lagarde at the helm of the ECB, there are at least two European policy makers who will be pushing for a thorough overhaul of fiscal policy in Europe.
Japan makes slight tweak
With central bank policy reviews very much in vogue, the Bank of Japan took the opportunity to tweak its own monetary policy. The logic was simple; the pandemic meant that monetary policy needed to be looser for longer and so the possible long-term side effects on the Japanese financial system should be studied and policy altered to make it more sustainable. In practice, this meant widening the bands around which the Bank purchases Japanese Government Bonds (JGBs) from +/- 20bps around zero to +/-25 bps around zero and the abandonment of their purchase target for Exchange Traded Funds. More interestingly, they introduced an ‘Interest Scheme to Promote Lending’ for banks, which pays attractive interest rates on bank reserves and could, in theory, allow the Bank of Japan to reduce interest rates further into negative territory whilst overcoming the effective tax this creates for commercial banks.
The Ministry of Finance’s fiscal 2021 budget aims to increase expenditure 8.4% over FY 2020. However, of the 5.2 trillon yen additional spending, 5 trillion yen is earmarked for ‘contingency funds for COVID’ and will pay for Japan’s vaccination programme. If this brings forward normal social interactions, it should help boost the economy.
Bank of England seeks to update its exit strategy
The Bank of England kept monetary policy unchanged over the quarter, having pre-emptively increased its QE programme by £150 billion in November. However, operationally, there were two interesting decisions. Firstly, the Prudential Regulation Authority’s (PRA) assessment and engagement with PRA-regulated firms on the possible implementation of a zero or negative Bank Rate found that, in the near term, such a decision “would attract increased operational risks.” With expectations that negative UK rates were a possibility, markets rapidly re-priced. The Bank, though, was more measured and whilst kicking the concept somewhat into the long grass, still wants lenders to prepare for the possibility. The second interesting decision was the instruction to staff to update the exit strategy from QE. In 2018, the plan was to keep the balance sheet unchanged until Bank Rate reached 1.5%. But with QE now the marginal tool, it looks like this guidance will be changed to enable an earlier run down of the Bank’s balance sheet.
Fiscal policy turned out somewhat looser than expected at the March Budget, with spending some £57 billion higher in FY21/22 than November’s guidance and the feared squeeze not kicking in significantly until FY24/25. Finally, the Budget also tweaked the Bank of England’s mandate in order to support a transition to a net zero carbon economy, subject to the price stability objective. In practice, this likely means a favourable collateral regime for green bonds.
1 Bank for International Settlements, as of 30 September, 2020